Five years after the post-pandemic surge in responsible investing, the rules, the market and the default funds themselves look very different; here is where ESG in workplace pensions actually stands for corporate advisers in late 2026.
In reading this article you will understand:
- Which ESG and climate rules now apply to trust-based and contract-based workplace pension schemes, and which proposals have stalled or been dropped.
- How market sentiment and provider default fund design have shifted since 2021, including the retreat from some net-zero alliances.
- How to frame ESG questions in a scheme review so that employer clients get a clear, evidence-based answer rather than a marketing one.
When Benefits Guru last looked at ESG in workplace pensions in 2021, responsible investment funds were setting monthly sales records and the direction of travel looked one-way. It hasn’t turned out like that. The Investment Association recorded net retail outflows of £4.7bn from responsible investment funds in 2024, and outflows continued through 2025 before slowing sharply in 2026. At the same time, the regulatory framework around sustainability claims has tightened, and several of the largest workplace default funds have been redesigned. For corporate advisers, the ESG question in a scheme review is no longer whether the provider talks about sustainability; it’s whether what it says can be evidenced.
The Rules That Now Apply
For trust-based schemes, the core climate duties have been in place for several years. The Occupational Pension Schemes (Climate Change Governance and Reporting) Regulations 2021 brought schemes with £5bn or more in assets, and all authorised master trusts, into TCFD-aligned climate reporting from October 2021, with schemes of £1bn to £5bn following from October 2022. Trustees in scope must carry out scenario analysis, set metrics and targets, and publish a climate report. The Pensions Regulator’s General Code, in force since 28 March 2024, goes further for all schemes: it expects a climate change policy, climate risk to be built into investment and risk management decisions, and stewardship on ESG matters that trustees cannot simply hand off to a manager.
On the contract-based side, the FCA’s TCFD-aligned disclosure rules (PS21/24) apply to asset managers, life insurers and FCA-regulated pension providers above £5bn, and Independent Governance Committees have been required since April 2020 to report on their provider’s ESG, non-financial and stewardship policies. The FCA’s anti-greenwashing rule, in force since 31 May 2024, applies to every authorised firm, which means a GPP provider’s sustainability claims to employers and members have to be fair, clear and capable of being substantiated.
What hasn’t happened matters just as much. The FCA’s Sustainability Disclosure Requirements and its four investment labels (Sustainability Focus, Sustainability Improvers, Sustainability Impact and Sustainability Mixed Goals) apply to UK funds, not to pension products, and the FCA’s plan to extend SDR to portfolio management was paused in 2025. There is no live proposal to extend labelling to workplace pensions. A clause in the Pension Schemes Bill that would have required statutory guidance on how trustees treat financially material factors such as climate was removed in the Lords; the Government has said it will still publish fiduciary duty guidance, but on a non-statutory basis, with a formal public consultation expected in late 2026 and final guidance expected between January and March 2027.
Several pieces are still in motion. The Government confirmed in June 2025 that the DWP would review the 2021 climate reporting regulations alongside its work on UK Sustainability Reporting Standards and transition plans; the final UK standards were published in February 2026 for voluntary use, with no mandate yet for pension schemes. tPR has worked with the industry on a voluntary net-zero transition plan template, and its 2026 to 2027 corporate plan commits it to publishing an approach to climate change and systemic risk. For now, advisers should treat these as signals of direction rather than new obligations.
How the Market Has Moved
The wider climate alliance landscape has fractured. The Net Zero Asset Managers initiative suspended its activities in January 2025 after BlackRock’s exit, before relaunching in February 2026 with a revised, less prescriptive commitment. The Net-Zero Banking Alliance voted to cease operations in October 2025. None of this changes a UK trustee’s legal duties, but it does mean an asset manager’s alliance membership is a weaker signal of intent than it was in 2021.
Workplace providers have responded in different ways. Scottish Widows’ redesigned Lifetime Investment default, launched in March 2025 and covering more than £60bn, tilts towards companies with positive impact against the UN Sustainable Development Goals. The People’s Pension moved £28bn of assets from State Street to Amundi and Invesco in February 2025, citing stewardship and responsible investment among its reasons. Meanwhile, the private markets push behind the Mansion House Accord is changing what sits in defaults more broadly; the Accord itself doesn’t set ESG criteria, so advisers should not assume a private markets allocation is a sustainability allocation.
What Members Say
Member attitudes remain supportive but shallow. Scottish Widows’ 2025 research found 72% of employees said a responsibly invested pension from their employer was important, yet 47% did not know whether theirs was invested responsibly, and only 17% named environmental and social impact as a priority. A YouGov poll for UKSIF in September 2025 found 79% of adults supported their pension being invested in renewable energy. For an employer, that combination of broad support and low awareness is a communications gap as much as an investment one.
What It Means for Advisers
The practical shift is from asking about intentions to asking for evidence. When reviewing a client’s default, look at the trustees’ published climate report or the IGC’s annual report, check what metrics and targets are actually being tracked, and ask how stewardship is carried out and reported. Treat net-zero pledges and alliance memberships as context rather than proof. Where an employer wants sustainability to be part of its benefits story, be clear about what the default does and doesn’t do, and whether a separate self-select option is a better fit for members who want more. The anti-greenwashing rule cuts both ways here: it protects members from overstated provider claims, and it is a reminder that advisers’ own descriptions of a scheme’s ESG credentials to an employer need to be just as well founded.
Things to reflect on for CPD
- Which of your employer clients’ schemes publish a climate report or IGC ESG assessment, and when did you last read it as part of a review?
- How would you explain to a scheme sponsor the difference between an asset manager’s net-zero commitment and the trustees’ own legal duties?
- Where a default now includes private markets, how would you check whether any sustainability claim attached to that allocation can be substantiated?
- How might low member awareness of responsible investment affect the way you advise an employer on scheme communications?

