The Consumer Duty has applied to contract-based workplace pensions since July 2023, and the FCA’s own reviews show where firms still fall short on members in vulnerable circumstances; this is what corporate advisers can reasonably expect from providers, and what to ask at scheme review.

In reading this article you will understand:

  • What the Consumer Duty and the FCA’s vulnerable customers guidance (FG21/1) require of group personal pension providers, and why the Duty does not apply to employers or occupational trustees.
  • What the FCA’s March 2025 review and its later work found about how firms identify and support customers with characteristics of vulnerability, and how tPR’s guidance now sets similar expectations for trust-based schemes.
  • Which questions to put to providers at scheme review, and how employer clients can help members get support without mishandling their personal data.

Three years after the Consumer Duty took effect for open products on 31 July 2023, support for members in vulnerable circumstances is something the FCA expects group personal pension (GPP) providers to evidence, through product governance, communications, service and the outcomes data they report to their own boards. The numbers involved remain large. The FCA’s Financial Lives 2024 survey, published in May 2025, found that 49% of UK adults, some 26.4 million people, showed one or more characteristics of vulnerability in 2024, down from 52% in 2022 on the FCA’s updated measure. For corporate advisers, the scheme review question has moved on from whether a provider has a vulnerability policy to whether it can show the policy works.

The Rules That Apply

The Duty applies only to firms carrying on FCA-regulated activities. For a workplace GPP, that means the provider as manufacturer and the adviser firm as distributor. Since 31 July 2024 it has also covered closed products, bringing older contract-based arrangements into scope. It does not apply to the employer in its role as scheme sponsor, and it generally does not reach the trustees of occupational schemes, master trusts included.

The FCA’s Guidance for firms on the fair treatment of vulnerable customers (FG21/1), published in February 2021, still sits alongside the Duty. It defines a vulnerable customer as someone who, due to their personal circumstances, is especially susceptible to harm, particularly when a firm is not acting with appropriate levels of care. Firms are expected to understand the needs of their customer base, equip staff to recognise and respond to them, reflect them in product design, service and communications, and monitor whether they are being met. The FCA also expects firms to make it easy for customers to share information about their needs and to be proactive in offering support.

Financial Lives tracks four drivers. In 2024, 26% of adults had low resilience, financial or emotional, 20% had a recent negative life event, 17% had low capability and 9% were in poor health. Each can surface in a pension: long-term sickness, bereavement, divorce, saving stopped under financial pressure, or a member near retirement who cannot follow the options.

What the FCA Found

The FCA published its review of firms’ treatment of customers in vulnerable circumstances on 7 March 2025. It drew on survey responses from 725 firms, follow-up requests to 29 firms across 12 markets and consumer research including a survey of 1,500 people. The review was cross-sector, but its weak spots map onto workplace pensions. Only 29% of firms said they tested the impact of a product or service on customers with characteristics of vulnerability and whether it met their needs, and the FCA said areas for improvement remained, particularly around products and services and outcomes monitoring.

The consumer research is just as relevant to scheme design. Only four in ten customers in vulnerable circumstances said they had disclosed their needs to a provider. Of those who did, 57% said the firm cared and 58% said it took action to give them the support they needed. Reasons for staying silent included embarrassment (37%), not wanting to be treated differently (24%) and worry about getting a worse deal (23%). Most workplace pension members rarely contact their provider, so that reluctance is the starting point. The FCA concluded that FG21/1 remains appropriate alongside the Duty and would not be updated.

A Consumer Duty review of 38 firms’ products and services, published on 10 July 2026 and again not pensions-specific, named identifying customers in vulnerable circumstances as an area for improvement and pressed firms to adapt products and services rather than stop at identification. The FCA’s pensions regulatory priorities report, published in March 2026, does not single out vulnerability; its focus is value for money, retirement journeys and targeted support, which went live on 6 April 2026. In its targeted support policy statement, PS25/22, the FCA said firms should consider the expectations in FG21/1 to respond flexibly to the needs of vulnerable consumers, which may mean additional or specific signposts.

Trust-Based Schemes and the Employer’s Role

Trust-based schemes sit outside the Duty, but expectations are converging. The Pensions Regulator’s (tPR) administration guidance for all schemes, published on 9 December 2025, says digital-first communication should still offer alternatives such as telephone, post, large print, braille or translated documents, which is especially important for vulnerable members who may need additional support. It points governing bodies to the FCA’s good practice on vulnerable customers, and its worked example has trustees asking their administrator for vulnerability handling statistics, including members identified and the support provided. It is guidance rather than a duty, but it supports similar questions across both scheme types.

Employers need more care. HR often hears about an illness, a bereavement or new caring responsibilities before the provider does, and it can be tempting to pass that on. Health information is special category data under UK GDPR. A joint FCA and ICO statement of 27 March 2026 confirms that data protection law does not stop firms delivering good outcomes under the Duty, but processing special category data still needs both a lawful basis and a separate condition. For most employer clients the better route is making sure members know how to tell the provider directly, and that HR and line managers know where to signpost them.

What to Ask at Scheme Review

Ask the provider how many of your client’s members it has identified as having characteristics of vulnerability, how that compares with the Financial Lives picture, and how recorded needs are used so members do not have to explain themselves twice. Ask whether default fund communications and retirement journeys have been tested with members in vulnerable circumstances, given how few firms reported doing so in 2025. Ask what its Consumer Duty board report, which must be produced at least once a year, says about outcomes for these members and what has changed as a result. If it offers targeted support, ask how it handles members for whom a ready-made suggestion would be unsuitable. And ask what aggregate management information the employer will see, so your client can judge whether its own communications reach the people who need them most.

The Duty applies to the adviser firm as well. Recommending a provider that cannot evidence its approach is harder to justify than in 2022, when the Duty was a year away; recording these questions and answers at each review helps show your own firm has met it.

Things to reflect on for CPD

  • For each GPP you advise on, what evidence has the provider given you, rather than a policy document, that members in vulnerable circumstances are getting good outcomes?
  • How would you explain to an employer client why the Consumer Duty applies to the provider and to your firm, but not to them as scheme sponsor?
  • What guidance do your employer clients give HR and line managers on signposting members to their pension provider, and does it avoid passing on health information without a proper basis?
  • Where a client uses a master trust, which of tPR’s administration guidance points on vulnerable members would you raise with the trustees or administrator at the next review?